Direct democracy. Zero capture.
Your vote
has a receipt.
Every vote is binding, permanent, and on the ledger. The Quiet Council enforces what you decide — it has no authority of its own. There is no general fund to capture and no landlord to negotiate with.
[Image: URBAL OS vote screen — December ballot, immutable ledger confirmation receipt]
Why this works here
Direct democracy isn't a policy choice URBAL made — it's what the Recipe's physical scale makes possible. A one-square-mile, 25,000-person town is small enough that every steward can actually read every proposal on the December ballot, and every vote changes a street they walk down. At 330 million, consequences are invisible and votes are symbolic. At this scale, they aren't.
Governance, at a glance
Trust doesn't require believing URBAL. It requires reading the chain.
Small enough that consequences land on the people who made them. Every vote, fee, and transfer recorded where anyone can check it.
25,000
The scale where bad decisions land on the people who made them. At 330 million, consequences are invisible. Here, your vote changes your street by January.
60% to pass
Yes, No, or Abstain. Vote Yes and you also set an intensity — the bar the measure must clear to be renewed later.
Flag in July, gone by January
No legacy leases, no tenure. The Mainstay removes operators who stop serving the community.
No general fund
Construction, ops, county, and 529 plans each hold separate escrows. Opacity is structurally impossible.
Immutable ledger
Every vote, fee, and transfer. Managed by independent custodians. URBAL cannot alter it — any steward or court can read it.
The annual cycle
Five months of argument. Three days of voting.
Nothing is decided in a single meeting, and nothing carries over undecided. The year runs the same way every year, and by December the arguments have already been made in public.
Aug – Oct · Digital baseline
Every steward works the question through the deliberation tool. Nobody's argument wins on presentation alone.
November · The debate hall
The strongest arguments are made in person, unamplified, Westminster form. The Keystone moderates without a position.
December · The vote
Three days. Voting is a lease condition — Abstain satisfies it. Every commercial lease is on the same ballot.
Every law carries a sunset. Nothing survives on inertia — if it is not actively re-ratified at its renewal bar, it expires cleanly and the town moves on.
Take a closer look
Nine interlocking mechanisms.
Steward vote
Steward vote mechanics
Three options. A 60% bar. A permanent receipt.
Stewards vote on every commercial lease in a three-day December window. There are three options — Yes, No, and Abstain — and all three count as participation. Abstain is deliberately not a spoiled ballot: it registers that you showed up without forcing a direction, and it is excluded from the directional count. A measure passes when at least 60% of the directional votes cast, meaning Yes and No only, are Yes. Voting runs on the town's own private municipal network rather than the public internet. Each vote writes immediately to the immutable ledger and produces a permanent receipt. No vote can be changed after it is cast.
Quiet Council role
Enforcement only. No authority of its own.
The Quiet Council holds 7 seats, allocated by zone: 1 Evelyn Rose, 2 Courtyard, 2 Wild Flower Garden, 1 Orchard Garden, 1 Vine Garden. Members are drawn by random lottery from the steward pool — like jury duty — from stewards aged 20 and over, and serve 2-year non-consecutive terms compensated at twice state median income. The Council has no judicial authority and no executive authority. Its sole function is execution, audit, and emergency response: ensuring that what stewards vote on actually happens — that flagged businesses lose their leases, that fee allocation changes are implemented, that December ballot results take effect without delay or interference. It also enforces the CLT ground lease escalator by flagging to the immutable ledger. The community is the authority. The Council makes sure it counts.
Commercial lease July flagging
Five months to improve before the ballot.
Any steward can flag an underperforming Spice Tray operator, employer, or inner-wall business in July. The flag triggers a public performance review and gives the operator five months to address community concerns. If the December ballot removes them, new operators compete for the vacancy starting January 1. No legacy position survives a majority who wants change.
December removal ballot
Three days. No noise. Decisive.
The December ballot covers every flagged business and every lease due for renewal. Voting runs on the town's own private municipal network — not the public internet. Stewards vote privately through URBAL OS: Yes, No, or Abstain on each question, with Abstain counting as participation but excluded from the directional tally. A lease renews when at least 60% of the directional votes are Yes. Stewards voting Yes also set an intensity between 60% and 90%, and the average of those becomes the bar that operator must clear at their next renewal — so a business that scrapes through on a lukewarm majority faces a harder test next year, not an easier one. Results are final, non-appealable, and on the ledger before midnight.
Immutable ledger record
Permanent. Auditable. Not controlled by URBAL.
The immutable distributed ledger is managed by the OCIO bank's independent custodian — not by URBAL Platform LLC. Every vote, fee allocation, PLC transfer, and construction draw is recorded permanently. Any steward, any external auditor, and any court can read the complete record. Altering it is technically impossible. Trust doesn't require believing URBAL — it requires reading the ledger.
One page. 10 point. No exceptions.
The constraint is the point.
Every proposal submitted to the December ballot is capped at a single page set in 10 point type. Exceed it and the submission is rejected at input — it is not trimmed, summarised, or returned for editing by anyone else. The cap does two things. It guarantees that every steward can actually read every proposal on the ballot in an evening, which is what makes universal participation realistic rather than notional. And it forces the author to know what they are asking for. A proposal that cannot survive a page was not ready.
The foundational policy layer
Ratified before the town opens. Harder to change.
A foundational layer of policy is ratified by the first cohort before the town opens, and it sits beneath ordinary governance. Amending it requires a materially higher threshold than the 60% that carries a normal measure — in the range of 70 to 75% — along with a longer deliberation window before the vote. Ordinary decisions should be easy to revisit; the rules that govern how decisions get made should not be. Measures also carry a term: one year where the town is experimenting, two or three where it wants stability.
Who runs the ledger
Town-operated. No human write access. No forking.
The ledger is operated by the town itself, on open source software, with no human write access and no ability to fork it — ever. The node operators are steward residents, governed by the foundational policy layer covering eligibility, rotation, uptime obligations, compensation, and term limits. This matters more than it sounds: a vote record is only as trustworthy as the people who could quietly rewrite it, so the answer is a system in which no one can, including URBAL.
Mutually exclusive escrows
No general fund. No pooled allocation. No capture.
Construction escrow, URBAL ops, county government share (3%), and county children's 529 plans (2%) hold separate accounts — never commingled, never discretionarily reallocated. Your monthly fee is itemized line by line. The general fund is where institutional capture happens. URBAL has no general fund.
Intensity thresholds
A narrow, passionate win is harder to renew.
If you vote Yes, you also set an intensity number between 60% and 90%, rounded to the nearest 5%. The average of every Yes voter's number becomes the bar that measure must clear when it comes up for renewal. This is the part people misread at first: the intensity does not decide the vote in front of you — it decides how much agreement the measure will need to survive next time. A narrow but passionate majority can therefore set a renewal bar harder to meet than the 60% that passed it in the first place. That is intentional. Conviction should make a decision durable, not permanent, and the people most certain about a measure are the ones asked to say how much consensus it ought to require.
Who the annual lease vote applies to
Every commercial relationship in the town. No exceptions.
The December lease vote applies to every commercial relationship, not just retail: Spice Tray operators (cafés, bakeries, galleries, performance venues, kiosks, workshops — up to 500 buildings across 24 corridors), inner wall clinics (physician LLCs, dentistry, pharmacy, optometry, mental health, specialist offices), teacher LLCs holding rooftop campus leases, and outer wall employers. Every one re-competes every December on the same ballot as everything else.
Mainstay status — earned, not permanent
Consistently high ratings skip the ballot. A poor year reopens it.
Operators with consistently high steward ratings over multiple annual cycles earn Mainstay designation — automatic renewal, no ballot unless formally challenged, and the best placement in their zone. It's earned from aggregate steward ratings, not assigned by URBAL and not purchased. A single poor year can reopen the ballot, and a formally challenged Mainstay operator returns to the same December vote as everyone else. Removed operators vacate January 1 and the waitlist competitor with the next-highest community score takes the space — no gap, no negotiation.
The Debate Chamber
The young argue. The old referee. Everyone else watches.
A Westminster-style chamber stands on a designated trust lot in the Evelyn Rose URB. It exists for civic formation, not policy — nothing decided on that floor binds the town. What happens there is that a generation learns to argue in public, in front of the people they will spend their lives among.
Exuberance · 20–28
They argue, and they are assigned their side rather than choosing it. You will spend evenings defending positions you do not hold, in front of your neighbours — which is the fastest way anyone has found to learn that the other side has reasons.
Keystone · 60–68
Lottery-selected referees who moderate the floor and hold no opinion on it. The chamber's authority rests with the people furthest from having anything to prove, and closest to having watched this argument before.
Agency · 28–60
The witnesses. They do not take the floor — they watch, and they carry the December vote. Children are welcome in the chamber, which is the entire point of putting it in a residential URB rather than a civic complex.
Debaters work in pairs
Every side is argued by a Chief Articulator and a Technical Expert together. The pairing is set by the apprenticeship track you took at 18 — Liberal Arts students articulate, Technical students carry the evidence. Neither can win the floor alone.
Personal attack forfeits everything
Attack the person rather than the argument and you lose the floor immediately, and the debate with it. The names of those who forfeit are cut into the granite Debate Roll in the chamber. The record is permanent because the standard has to be.
It scales with the system
The chamber runs at town level, then into the Bunch city, then as a Bouquet-wide round robin. A steward who is good at this is known well beyond their own square mile.
Your vote, your town